I really don't understand this, at all. help?!?

So it seems to me like most guys like a girl whose real and doesn't wear makeup. Okay, so then why is it that all the fake, makeup splattered girls are always the ones being called pretty and hot. Why are they the ones who get boyfriend after boyfriend. Okay, I like wearing makeup, because I know it makes me look prettier. Makeup makes everyone look prettier. I don't get why guys lie and pretend it doesn't because if that was really the case, they would't be drooling over the fake little *****es that need a chisel to get their makeup off. I am so confused now. I am going to me moving to a new school, and I believe strongly that I will make a better first impression if I wear a bit of makeup. (not alot like fake alot, but a decent amount) then again guys keep saying they like it better when a girl goes natural. Obviously it can't be both ways so which is it? All I know is I have some acne problems and makeup was a way i look and feel confident but it seems like no matter what I do now I just can't win. If I wear makeup- Im not a naturally pretty girl. Instead Im a fake. If I don't wear makeup- no guy will even look twice at me and if they do it's cuz they cant believe how terrbile my skin is. So what should I do? Help?